Amazing Custom

We used Lucy's for our wedding on Water Island this past January 2021. We were blown away by their amazing customer service and attention to detail. We ordered a variety of cakes and pastries for our guest and everything was delicious, fresh and beautifully done. I can go on-and-on but Lucy's gets our top recommendation! I would have given them more stars if possible! Thank you to the team at Lucy's for making our desert dreams come true on our wedding day! Jennifer and Matthew WI wedding 1/14/2021

I actually love this business. She is very professional and meticulous with her designs. Oh and I had a 2 tier featuring rainbow on the top tier and carrot on the bottom tier. Oh and the taste!!!!! Both cakes' taste were on point!!! I had cake for breakfast and lunch!! Omg!! My diet!! Lucy's keep up the fantastic work!!!!

Very professional young woman .. Most of Lucy's make every single cake from scratch.. No box cake all made with her hands. Keep up the good work!!! GOD BLESS!!

I traveled to St. Thomas with my girlfriend for her birthday in November of 2020 and I needed to find a local bakery to do a carrot cake (my girlfriend’s favorite). I reached out to about 3 different bakeries and one responded. That response was Lucy! Boy am I glad she did. She was very helpful and attentive to my needs. She has the sweetest soul and truly treated me like family. On top of all that, THE CAKE WAS AMAZING!!! My girlfriend, still talks about how good it was. If my travels take me back to St. Thomas, Lucy’s is definitely on my list of places to go!

Ordered a Minnie Mouse Cake for my daughter’s 2nd Birthday and I was more than satisfied! The cake was beautifully made and so pretty, you wont like to cut it. It really exceeded my expectation!

I came to the Virgin Islands to preach and knowing that I am a Pittsburgh Steelers fan they had arrange for a Special Cake prepared for me by Lucy Cakes. Not only was the design a great surprise, but the cake was delicious. Thank you Lady for you Excellent Bakery Skills!

Magnificent food conveniently located inside the mall and amazing, friendly service. Thanks for making our trip special! 5/5 would recommend for a great breakfast / lunch food spot.

My sister was celebrating her birthday in St Thomas (last minute) and we tried several places to get a cake. Everyone was already booked. (Holiday wknd and valentines wknd) I called Lucy’s and even though she was booked she still agreed to accommodate me. The cake was beautiful and tasted sooo good we decided to cut what was left and bring back to the states! Need a bakery, look no further!

Thank you Lucy's cake for making an awesome cake for my mother Mrs. L Nibbs! She really enjoyed every inch of her birthday cake. I stated what I wanted from Atlanta over the phone and you made my mother's birthday dreams come through. This is one birthday she'll never forget!

Lucy made a crazy nice cake for my wife’s 40th bday, cinnamon rolls, and bread pudding. I imagine anything that comes out of her kitchen is awesome.

It was a pleasure working with Lucy’s Cakes & her staff. Very flexible and very helpful with suggestions in coming up with a concept for the cake. She made planning my wife’s 40th birthday celebration go perfectly. All of our guests were very pleased and raved how great the cake & fresh fruit platter tasted. I would use them in a heartbeat & recommend them to anyone visiting the Virgin Islands.

Absolutely delicious! Not only was the cake itself so delicious, but they whipped up exactly what I was looking for! golf ball cake to celebrate my MIL retirement. It was perfect. We were on the island only a couple days, and this cake was devoured before we left. So yummy!

This is the place to get anything when traveling to the island!!! THESE LADIES ARE AAAAMAZING! The quality for the price is unheard of on the mainland. We traveled from Virginia for my girlfriends birthday and I took a leap of faith in ordering and prepaying. I sent them a couple of pictures as my gfs favorite cake is confetti. Again we couldn’t be happier and we ate on this our whole week there. Thank you so much for making our trip so special. We can’t wait to come back and will definitely be ordering again but with a cheesecake too!!! Best wishes!

Lucy’s Cake & Cafe team are exceptional! I’ve ordered a one-tier rum cake with pineapple and cream of coconut filling. The cake was delicious and adorned with real orchids with hand-painted detailing. The ladies really came through to bring my cake vision to real-life. I’ve traveled with some girlfriends to celebrate my 30th birthday in the US Virgin Islands and they made the process so smooth. Always responding to my emails, texts, questions, and making sure the cake arrived in pristine conditions and on-time. All I wished was to take some of the cake back home with me. I can’t thank the ladies enough. Such great attention to detail, amazing customer service, and best in taste and design. Highly-recommended!